Dedicated To The Smallest Of Skiffs banner

Soft Tackle Box - Best bet for the $$?

1 reading
10K views 48 replies 36 participants last post by  captainjz16  
#1 ·
I’m tired replacing my soft tackle box every year due to frozen zippers.

What is a good dependable soft tackle box that will last more than a year?

Thank you!
 
#2 ·


I dont use a soft bag but some buddies will bring these on the boat and they seem to be very well built. The Patagonia one can be left unzipped with the magnetic closure strap engaged and stays shut which is nice.

My buddy with the Patagonia one has had it for a few years and it doesn't seem to have had any issues. Dont have any time/testing with the fishpond one aside from one or two experiences but it seemed well built as well.
 
#3 ·
Just something to entertain. My son hates his hard tackle box. Similar to the one blow. We have been looking for a soft tackle box for him. While we looked I let him borrow an old backpack. It's 20 years old. The reason I know this it was the "daddy diaper bag" I had from when he was little. Turns out it makes a great tackle backpack. May want to see if you have any old backpacks laying around. They work great.

 
#4 ·
I'll second a slight re-purposing. I've been using Gill laptop computer bags for 10+ years (on my second but the first was still going strong when I swapped out). Plenty of zipper pockets and enough room for multiple boxes/soft plastic binder. The zippers have held up well, but my bag lives in the forward hatch when fishing or in the tackle room when idle.
 
#13 ·
I am going on about 6 years with an older Plano Z-Series bag. It has no zippers, uses buckles to close so no freezing in salt water. The other pockets use Velcro. I've been happy with it and will buy another when it does give out.

View attachment 255486
I have the same one and it has been good for me also, no zippers and 5+ years old but they don't make it anymore. Just decided to replace mine and went with the new version.
Image
 
#6 ·
I had an Orvis bag for a for years but the best is this $42 Husky Office Pro. I'm usually a guy that says you get what you pay for this $42 bag is far superior to my $230 Orvis bag. Going on 5 years not and functions like new. 3700 boxes fit perfectly if you take a razor and cut out other canvas divider.

 
#10 ·
I use this thing - it's a BEAST, but man, it's the only thing that holds everything I need AND is convenient when I'm fishing. The only zipper that froze on me in the last 5 or so years is one of the side pockets. I use the crap out of that bag, and it's starting to fall apart, but certainly the best layout and durability of any bag I've ever used. Being able to keep my zmans up top and storage trays in the front is awesome.

 
#43 ·
I use this thing - it's a BEAST, but man, it's the only thing that holds everything I need AND is convenient when I'm fishing. The only zipper that froze on me in the last 5 or so years is one of the side pockets. I use the crap out of that bag, and it's starting to fall apart, but certainly the best layout and durability of any bag I've ever used. Being able to keep my zmans up top and storage trays in the front is awesome.

Does the compartment for the storage trays come already assembled? This looks like a really nice bag. I ordered one of the AFTCO ones with a similar design, and you had to basically build the interior storage liners yourself with their velcro lined liners. It was such a pain in the ass to get them lined up right and they never seemed secure. I returned it. You can see what I mean in this picture. You can remove those liners...which seems cool in theory but it was not for me.

Image
 
#14 ·
I've been using the Plano Guide series for over a year now. Hands down favorite bag I've owned and no issues with the zippers. They come in a ton of different sizes depending on what you want. The top is magnetic and has been great for keeping nippers and spare flies handy.
 
#16 · (Edited)
I have the older model Patagonia (the gray one with the flyfishing logo) and I'd be hesitant to recommend one from them. After years of good service, it simply fell apart at the seams one day-- almost as if the glue melted. Granted, it was one of those 110-degrees-in-the- shade days, but something made for fishing should be able to withstand some heat/sun exposure. I tried to get a replacement, but Patagonia wanted me to mail it in for "evaluation" and couldn't confirm that they'd send me a new one OR the old one back. They also said that they were having some supply-chain issues and didn't have any new ones in stock, etc. etc. I may dig it out and try the return again, but I wouldn't buy another one unless it was a screaming deal.
Edited to add photos. Eventually, all the seams failed in the same manner.
Image

Image
 
#18 ·
It's not a soft bag but I really like the Yeti Go-Box. The only issue is that 3700 series Plano boxes don't really fit well and I really like the Plano Edge 3700 Thin boxes I have.

I have one Go-Box for offhshore tackle and another for bottom fishing and reef tackle but I've stuck with my $42 Husky Office organizer for inshore because of the way the boxes fit and I like the molded tray top.
 
#28 ·
Another vote for the Plano Guide series. My wife paid too much for it, but it’s awesome. I really like the hard bottom for keeping it dry if a little water shifts as I move around. The 3600 series helps keep me from carrying too much stuff. I just swap boxes from inshore to offshore gear. Not the easiest to find, but the deep 3600 boxes are perfect for offshore lures.
 
#29 ·
I didn't expect the Plano Guide to hold up as well as it has when I first got it. It sat out in the open on our first skiff and got a ton of spray. I have not lubricated the zippers yet, and they all still work very well. The only thing that has given out is the stitching on the pad of the shoulder strap. Wasn't a big deal for me because I don't have to carry it far and it honestly just got in the way. The plastic molded tooth zippers hold up well compared to the metal ones I have on some older tackle bags. Those need more care to keep them running smooth.
 
#30 ·
Here’s the one I have. This is my second one and I bought another backup when they had them on sale. They last a few years no issues. They actually come with a Plano tackle tray that fits in the front zipper. I put my line spools in the side pouches and whatever in the rest. Insulated and waterproof so you can also use it as a cooler. @JC Designs bought one as well. Hard to find but I think you can dig one up.

 
#32 ·
Here’s the one I have. This is my second one and I bought another backup when they had them on sale. They last a few years no issues. They actually come with a Plano tackle tray that fits in the front zipper. I put my line spools in the side pouches and whatever in the rest. Insulated and waterproof so you can also use it as a cooler. @JC Designs bought one as well. Hard to find but I think you can dig one up.

Yeah, they need to bring them back!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Smackdaddy53
#31 ·
I have a Simms tackle bag that I've had for years. I've made a practice of using Star Bright Snap & Zipper Lubricant periodically, so I've never had any issues. Sometimes when fishing as a guest on another skiff, I'll throw a box or two and my other gear in a Simms Dry Creek Z Sling Pack and that has also worked out really well.
 
#33 ·
Plano is still the best option for soft tackle bags with buckles. Unfortunately tackle bag options have not improved over the years. Often the discontinued versions are much better. I think that's why you are seeing more and more people using dry bags, boat bags, etc.. to carry their tackle trays instead of intended use tackle bags.