Check out turning point propellors. I have the same motor as you with a 15 pitch. Was about $150 new. The best thing is they have removable hubs. So if you ever blow a hub, it can be fixed on the water (if you have a spare). And if you ever get a different motor (merc) you can just get a different splined hub.
A forum community dedicated to Small Skiff owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about engines, modifications, classifieds, troubleshooting, fishing, boating, poles, maintenance, and more!