[Caleb.Esparza]

I have fished on both extensively. They both ride pretty similar in the rough stuff, as in neither of them is ideal but very very doable with a skilled driver. Caimen will be drier and slightly smoother, Waterman runs skinnier with a JP. Both pole skinny enough for 98% of situations out there but I prefer poling the waterman. I give the edge to the waterman 18 for the extra stability and roomier cockpit all things being considered. Especially if it’s a Tom built waterman pre-reissue from HB.

Trolling motors are a non-starter for either skiff

 

[Caleb.Esparza]

Any skiff (Marquesa, HPX-V, Vantage, Cayo, Chittum, etc.) and even a 32’ Contender will beat your teeth in if you drive like a d*ckhead and/or lack basic seamanship skills. I’ve been in some legitimately heavy conditions well offshore in an 18’ waterman and I won’t say it wasn’t a slower ride in, but we made it back without any issues.